The Rabbit Hole of Substantive Testing

2025-11-04T13:02:54+02:00

What’s News? Your Content Goes Here For decades now, audit firms, especially small firms, or SMPs, as they are known nowadays, have insisted on the substantive approach, without any regard for controls. This was due to fears of blowing the budget, not knowing how to audit systems, or deciding that they would have to go substantive anyway, when controls prove to be ineffective. The result was that the audit client received less bang for their buck, in that feedback on system weaknesses was shoddy, and risks were not properly identified, as the requirements of ISA315 were interpreted as that [...]

The Rabbit Hole of Substantive Testing2025-11-04T13:02:54+02:00

Taking responsibility for quality on the engagement – Partner or EQR

2025-09-29T18:47:10+02:00

What’s News? Your Content Goes Here With the implementation of quality management systems to comply with ISQM, audit firms are compelled to be aware of threats to the ability of engagement teams to issue appropriate audit reports, and threats to the system of quality management to ensure that the firm as a whole does not issue inappropriate audit reports. When an engagement partner is nervous about a new industry, a very large client, or a complex audit, as examples, this would be seen as a threat. Typically, these threats require immediate attention, and engagement monitoring reviews will address [...]

Taking responsibility for quality on the engagement – Partner or EQR2025-09-29T18:47:10+02:00

Auditor and AI–How the Documentation Fixation will Blow Up in Our Faces

2025-08-26T11:05:22+02:00

What’s News? Your Content Goes Here Auditors are all excited about the advancements in AI, and are scrambling to implement this tool in the enhancement of their procedures on the one hand, while trying to figure out policies to curtail its abuse, and guide its proper use, on the other. In the meantime, they don’t have a clue about where its boundaries are, and what it is capable of. The intention is not to give you the solution to any of these mentioned dilemmas, but to pull you back to two basic audit and audit regulation principles. The [...]

Auditor and AI–How the Documentation Fixation will Blow Up in Our Faces2025-08-26T11:05:22+02:00

New business challenges to small and medium practices (SMPs)

2025-05-29T15:08:15+02:00

What’s News? Your Content Goes Here With increasing regulatory demands, many small and medium-sized audit practices (SMPs) have shifted their focus almost entirely to compliance — often at the expense of essential business practices. While ISQM 1 and ISQM 2 introduce some business-aligned principles, they are frequently applied in a narrow, compliance-driven manner, rather than being integrated into the firm's broader operations. To truly benefit, firms should approach these requirements by asking, ‘What is the purpose?’, ‘What processes already address this?’ and ‘How can we adapt them to support both business efficiency and audit quality?’ Beyond the standards, [...]

New business challenges to small and medium practices (SMPs)2025-05-29T15:08:15+02:00

AI and the Audit Profession – Highlighting Current Inadequacies

2025-05-29T15:08:39+02:00

What’s News? Your Content Goes Here I have been in the audit profession for 43 years now. I was blessed to be with a ‘big eight’ firm when I started, at a time when there were no formal auditing standards to speak of, but I was trained in risk-based auditing. I became involved in a small audit division where one would be involved in the accounting and tax of a client, as well, and sometimes, producing monthly management reports, with discussions of business performance and issues with clients. The intricate knowledge of the business and the affairs of [...]

AI and the Audit Profession – Highlighting Current Inadequacies2025-05-29T15:08:39+02:00

Scepticism and Reasons for Audit Failures

2025-03-28T14:47:05+02:00

What’s News? Your Content Goes Here The largest risk for an auditor is an audit failure, i.e. where the audit report issued was inappropriate. This can only occur when there is a lack of evidence to support the audit opinion issued. In most cases, a material balance or disclosure, or the completeness of balances and disclosures are not appropriately addressed. Management of the auditee, who spend a whole year working on the business generating the financial results, rely on the auditors to be knowledgeable enough to point out deficiencies to them. In order to address the full spectrum [...]

Scepticism and Reasons for Audit Failures2025-03-28T14:47:05+02:00

File Accessibility, Integrity and Security in the Context of ISQM 1 and Regulatory Standards

2025-03-07T12:13:18+02:00

What’s News? Your Content Goes Here With the advent of quality management standards, such as the International Standard on Quality Management 1 (ISQM 1), and the stricter regulation of file lockdown procedures and archiving, many firms have had to adapt their procedures to control the lockdown of engagement files, and the retention of system and engagement files. However, one critical aspect that is often overlooked is the integrity of the files. It is an area which is easily overlooked, as the content of files can’t be easily checked or monitored. Regulatory considerations and the importance of file integrity [...]

File Accessibility, Integrity and Security in the Context of ISQM 1 and Regulatory Standards2025-03-07T12:13:18+02:00

Key Amendments to the Companies Act Effective 27 December 2024: What You Need to Know

2025-02-04T14:10:56+02:00

What’s News? Your Content Goes Here On 27 December 2024, certain sections of the Companies Amendment Act 16 of 2024 became effective, including: Section 16, dealing with the effective date of MOI changes Section 45, which now sets out that the provisions of this section do not apply to the giving by a company of financial assistance to, or for the benefit of its subsidiaries Section 61, which requires the presentation of a social and ethics committee report, and the appointment of the social and ethics committee members at the AGM Section 72, with all the updated requirements [...]

Key Amendments to the Companies Act Effective 27 December 2024: What You Need to Know2025-02-04T14:10:56+02:00

Common Findings in Audit Engagement Monitoring File Reviews by LEAF during 2024

2024-11-28T16:17:44+02:00

What’s News? Your Content Goes Here After a year of insightful monitoring- and EQR reviews, LEAF has identified recurring findings during audit engagement file monitoring reviews across various industries. They are all similar to the IRBA themes of findings experienced during engagement inspections. Improving quality requires a mind shift from pure completion of methodology and templates, without regard for the circumstances of the audit, and the intentions of standards, to a clear knowledge of the circumstances of the audited entity and its business, and how the auditing and accounting standards are applied, without being led by generalised programmes. [...]

Common Findings in Audit Engagement Monitoring File Reviews by LEAF during 20242024-11-28T16:17:44+02:00

The Use of AI in the SMP and Small Audit Environment

2024-11-28T14:30:30+02:00

What’s News? Your Content Goes Here Artificial Intelligence (AI) is very topical, and hundreds of variations of AI are already on offer to solve a variety of problems. There are innumerable arguments for and against AI in the audit profession. Many small and medium practices (SMP), ours included, watched its emergence intently, like a tennis match, without knowing whether it was relevant; how the regulators viewed the future with AI; how it could be used by staff to manipulate audit procedures; and how it could be used to the benefit of an audit. These questions can only be [...]

The Use of AI in the SMP and Small Audit Environment2024-11-28T14:30:30+02:00
Go to Top